“Anne Will” to the Catholic Church: Much humility, few guarantees (TV criticism)

TV Criticism

It was as certain as the famous Amen in church – in times of the pandemic – that Anne Will on Sunday is about those, about Corona, vaccination, infection control measures and so on. Now, however, an independent legal report has revealed evidence of at least 497 victims of abuse in the Archdiocese of Munich and Freising between 1945 and 2019. 235 perpetrators were identified in the study, including 173 Catholic priests. This even scares Anne Will: “Abuse, lies, cover-ups – can this church still be saved?”

Who discussed?

How did the discussion go?

The debate begins once again with what Christiane Florin “Demutsgigantismus” names. Bishop Bätzing, the highest Catholic in the country by office, speaks of one “system failure of the church”, from “institutional failure”, of a “immense damage”, which is irreparable. He advises the emeritus Pope Benedict XVI, who has just been convicted of lying, to disregard his advisors and say: “I have taken guilt on myself. I’m sorry.” The Catholic Church still believes in miracles.

The lawyers at the Munich law firm Westpfahl Spilker Wastl spoke of one when the report was presented “Balance sheet of terror”. They proved that those responsible in the Archdiocese had violated numerous disclosure obligations and the protection of criminals who had been convicted. The allegations are directed not only against Joseph Ratzinger, but also against the incumbent Archbishop Reinhard Marx. “We see disaster”, said Marx – but he did not want to resign. However, this is exactly what Matthias Katsch, the spokesman for the initiative for those affected, is now demanding “Square table” from him – although he Marx a “genuine concern” granted and although it is also clear to him: “Changing people doesn’t change anything”. Katsch even demands one “system change”, without it being quite clear what it should consist of.

Christiane Florin also complains that all those responsible in the Catholic Church are still in office and dignified, although the systematic abuse within the Church has been discussed since 2010. In addition to the resignation of those responsible, church critic Ingrid Matthäus-Maier also – and above all – calls for the perpetrators to be banned from their profession, for all archives to be opened, and for investigations by secular public prosecutors to be carried out against all those perpetrators who are still alive. She criticizes them “rhetoric of dismay” the clergy and the “Kumpanei” politics with the Christian churches in the country. Only 41 cases from the Archdiocese of Munich and Freising have now been handed over to the public prosecutor, says Matthäus-Maier – and that too anonymously. “All crimes must be ruthlessly cleared up”, says Bätzing, who emphasizes that there are indeed consequences that would be drawn.

Katrin Göring-Eckardt, who demands from the church leaders that they should “Make room for other structures”, is now campaigning for an independent investigation of the cases of abuse in the Bundestag. Bätzing is also for it – “Of course”. So far, the church has always kept up with all the processing work “the booklet in hand”, says Florin, that of politics “bite inhibition” attested After all, the churches do a lot of social work that the state would otherwise have to do, so politicians don’t want to mess with the churches too much.

“Politics failed”, says Matthäus-Maier – with a view to church labor law that allows Catholics to discriminate against women or queer people in the name of religious freedom and self-determination. The traffic light coalition wants now “together with the churches” Reforms in ecclesiastical labor law “check”. That is politically the weakest possible statement, and the Greens Göring-Eckardt want it differently than Matthäus-Maier, for example “change, not abolish”.

Bätzing says he cannot guarantee that queer people like the 125 who have just come out to the media will not be fired from his church – but he wants to guarantee that. He even goes so far as to say that he “very happy” be about the outing. Although his church continues to brand homosexuality as a sin. So can he give guarantees for queer employees in the official church? Katsch reminds him that even the German Bishops’ Conference cannot ignore the teachings of the Church in Rome. In his closing remarks he demands once more “adequate compensation payments” for the victims of church abuse. And at this point Bätzing does not want to give any guarantees.

The special moment

In the late autumn of last year, Christiane Florin herself had an appointment to leave the church, but at the same time a Catholic priest was also tried in court – she then decided on the latter appointment, she says. She still hasn’t left the church: “I keep running away”.

The findings

In 2020, the Catholic Church received around 6.45 billion euros and the Evangelical Church around 5.63 billion euros from church tax, says the Federal Statistical Office. In addition, there are 548 million euros in state payments – a compensation for secularization in the 19th century – since the Second World War, 22 billion euros have been paid by the state to the churches, says Matthäus-Maier. “These state services can no longer be made understandable”, says Bätzing. The traffic light government has decided to change something about these payments – together with the churches.

Conclusion

Can the Catholic Church still be saved? In the end, this question remains open. But maybe it was just a rhetorical one anyway.